Loosing The Breast Cancer War - Part 2

Case 1was hard. A CT scan showed a 4 mm nodule in the
Jean (not real name) is a 56-year-old female.peripheral upper lobe of her right lung. There were
Sometime in 2004, she felt a hard, flat lump in hermultiple nodules in both lobes of her liver. There was
right breast. A mastectomy was done in Octoberalso a local lytic lesion in her L2 vertebra. There was
2004. The pathology report indicated infiltrating ductalslight central disc protrusion at C5/6. These findings
carcinoma, Grade 3.indicated that the caner had spread to her liver and
Jean underwent six cycles of chemotherapy withbone. According to the radiologist, the lesion in her
FEC (5-FU + Epirubicin + cyclophosphamide). Inlung was probably a granuloma.
addition, she had twenty sessions of radiationLi underwent another six cycles of chemotherapy.
treatment. All treatments were completed in JuneAfter the fourth chemo-cycle, a CT scan indicated
2006.that there was reduction of the size and number of
Barely three months later Jean was told that theliver lesions. However, at completion of the sixth
cancer had spread to her liver. On 4 Septemberchemo, this initial "success" proved shor-lived. The
2006, she underwent another cycle ofliver tumours had grown in size.
chemotherapy. This time the treatment causedA CT san in May 2007 showed lytic lesion in the
severe side effects. Jean decided to forgo thebody of T12 and L2 in keeping with bony metastasis.
remaining five cycles of chemotherapy.The oncologist wrote: "In view of the increasing size
Case 2of the liver metastases and the increasing bone
Li is a forty-one-year-old lady. She was my studentmetastasis, features are suggestive of progression
some years ago. After graduation from the universityof the disease." The oncologist told Li that he had to
she became a science teacher. Sometime in 2004, Lichange to new drugs. Li dared not go for more
felt three lumps in her left breast after being taughtchemotherapy and was in a limbo. She came to seek
how to self-breast examination (SBE) by a nurse. Shemy help. She presented with distended abdomen,
went to consult a doctor who then proceeded to doswelling of her left arm and both legs.
a lumpectomy to remove the lumps. The subsequentComments
histopathological report confirmed malignant tumors. AThe above episodes are real tragic -- again calling in
few days later, Li had her entire left breast removedquestion the effectiveness of the so-called "proven"
at a government hospital. After this mastectomy Litherapies for breast cancer. Li received all the
received eight cycles of chemotherapy and twentytreatments available but within three years she
sessions of radiation treatment. After the completionended up worse off that she started with. I would
of these treatments, Li took tamoxifen for twolike to pose on question: If Li were to do nothing,
years, until January 2007. At the same time as shewould she suffer these metastases to the liver and
was started on tamoxifen, Li was also asked to takebones? Over a decade of helping cancer patients, I
Zoladex (goserelin acetate) -- a chemical way ofhave this to say: "No, Li might not have suffered
destroying her ovaries to stop the production ofsuch unfortunate fate. I know of many patients from
females hormones. She was given Zoladex once aIndonesia who relied on their "jamu" or traditional
month, every month for a period of two years.herbal medication, and they do generally do not
In mid-January 2007, Li started to have stomachsuffer such severe metastasis within three years.
discomforts and her abdomen became bloated and